PayIt2 vs Donorbox
Flat per-transaction fee with no tier ladder. Combined ticketed events and donations on the same campaign. PayIt2 is open to individuals, attorneys, and small organizations as well as nonprofits.
The 30-second verdict
Side-by-side comparison
Donorbox is built for established 501(c)(3) nonprofits with recurring donor relationships. The differences matter most when your organization is small, your cause is outside Donorbox's mainstream lane, or you need ticketed events.
| Donorbox | PayIt2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Standard tier | Free; 2.95% platform fee on donation forms / 3.95% on events and memberships | Flat 3.85% per donation; $1.49 per event ticket. No tier ladder. |
| Paid Pro tier | $150/month; 1.75% platform fee on donation forms / 2% on events and memberships | No paid tier. All features included in the standard per-transaction fee. |
| Premium tier | Contact for pricing; 1.6% platform fee on donation forms / 2% on events and memberships | No premium tier. |
| Payment processing | Stripe 2.2% + $0.30 (nonprofit rate); PayPal 1.99% + $0.49 (non-AMEX); ACH 0.8% capped at $5 | 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction (Stripe) |
| Pass fees to donors | Yes, configurable on the donation form | Yes. Donors can cover all fees so 100% reaches your cause. |
| Payout speed | Donorbox uses your chosen processor (Stripe, PayPal, etc); timing follows that processor | 2 to 3 business days via Stripe |
| Recurring donations | Strong: monthly/quarterly/annual flows, donor self-management portals | Supported, less specialized; PayIt2 focuses on campaign-driven rather than ongoing-relationship fundraising |
| Event ticketing + donations | Donorbox handles events and donation forms as separate flows | Combined. Tickets and donations on one campaign URL. |
| Approval / signup | Standard tier has a quick signup; check Donorbox's current AUP for specific cause types | No pre-launch review for lawful causes. Launch in minutes. |
| AI tools for organizers | Not listed as a native feature on the pricing page; AI integrations via third-party | PayIt2 Campaign Assistant Claude plugin: creates, promotes, and optimizes campaigns via conversation |
Comparison information verified June 9, 2026 from Donorbox's public pricing page. Competitors may change pricing or features. Verify current details directly before relying on this comparison for a decision.
Should you pick PayIt2 or Donorbox?
A direct answer that respects your time. Each platform fits a different organization.
Pick Donorbox when
- You are an established 501(c)(3) with a stable recurring-donor program where Donorbox's specialized recurring tools and lower per-transaction fees (2.2% nonprofit Stripe rate) compound
- You expect enough donation volume that the Pro tier at $150/mo (with 1.75-2% platform fees) pencils out vs the Standard tier's 2.95-3.95%
- You want strong recurring-donor self-management and donor-portal features
Pick PayIt2 when
- You want a flat, predictable per-transaction fee with no tier upgrade required for features
- You are running ticketed events and want tickets + donations on the same campaign
- You are an individual, family, attorney, or small organization without 501(c)(3) status
- You want funds in your bank in 2 to 3 business days via Stripe's standard schedule
- You want AI campaign help via Claude plugin rather than third-party integrations
Frequently asked questions
It depends on which tier and processor you choose. On Donorbox's Standard tier (free monthly), the platform fee is 2.95% on donation forms (or 3.95% on events/memberships), then Stripe's 2.2% nonprofit rate. On the Pro tier ($150/mo), the platform fee drops to 1.75% on donation forms. For PayIt2, it's a flat 3.85% per donation plus 2.9% + $0.30 Stripe processing. For high-volume verified 501(c)(3) nonprofits, Donorbox's Pro tier can be cheaper per donation; for low-volume or non-nonprofit organizers, PayIt2 is simpler with no monthly commitment.
Donorbox targets nonprofits and may require nonprofit verification depending on the campaign. Verify Donorbox's current acceptable use policy for your specific cause. PayIt2 is the open-platform alternative for legal defense fundraising regardless of nonprofit status, with no campaign bans based on the nature of the cause. See the legal defense page.
Yes, but recurring donations are not PayIt2's primary focus. Donors can elect to repeat their donation but PayIt2 does not currently offer Donorbox's specialized donor self-management portal or advanced recurring-program reporting. If recurring fundraising is the bulk of your operation, Donorbox is the more specialized fit.
Yes. PayIt2 campaigns can include paid event tickets ($1.49 per ticket flat) and optional donations on the same campaign URL. This is particularly useful for fundraising galas, school auctions, and community fundraisers where some attendees buy tickets and others contribute without attending.
Yes. Create a PayIt2 campaign, transfer your story and content, and email your existing donor list with the new link. Recurring-donor migration depends on whether donors authorize new recurring agreements; one-time donors can simply use the new link.
PayIt2 transfers funds within 2 to 3 business days of every transaction via Stripe. Donorbox lets you choose your processor (Stripe, PayPal, ACH); the payout window follows whichever processor you select. If you connect Stripe on Donorbox, the timing is similar to PayIt2; on other processors it varies.
Start your campaign on the open platform
Transparent fees with no monthly tier upgrade. Combine tickets and donations on one campaign. Open to any lawful cause. Funds in your bank in 2 to 3 business days.